Best Sites To Buy Indie Game Merch

It’s a tale as old as time: when we find something we love, whether it be a game, a movie, a TV show, or a celebrity, we tend to want to showcase that in any way we can.

Sure, we can do this by shouting from the rooftops why our beloved media is the best of the best, but usually, this isn’t exactly socially acceptable. So, we, as gamers, tend to go for the next best thing: Merch!

The only problem for Indie fans specifically is that finding Indie Game Merch is a little bit trickier than finding merch for uber-popular AAA games with millions of fans. Indie fans need to dig a little deeper to find ways to show their love for their all-time favorite games. 

But don’t worry, we have you covered. We have created a list of eight amazing indie merch sites that will allow you to find exactly what you are looking for, and probably a few more extras on top of that. So, without further ado, here is Indie Game Culture’s Best Sites to Buy Indie Game Merch in 2024 Guide! 

Discover the Enigmatic World of Hollow Knight | GOG

Immerse yourself in the hauntingly beautiful world of "Hollow Knight," where every step unveils secrets and challenges waiting to be conquered. With its captivating art style and intricate gameplay, embark on an epic journey filled with mystery, danger, and discovery unlike any other.

Check Price
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

1. Sanshee 

When I first stumbled upon Sanshee, it felt like walking into a secret club for indie game enthusiasts. Their collection is a vibrant tapestry of indie gaming culture, showcasing an eclectic mix of merchandise that goes beyond the usual t-shirts and posters. But also, it has plenty of AA and AAA offerings, too, if that’s your poison. 

Above all, Sanshee excels when it comes to offering fans high-quality Plushies, Pins, and Stickers. I still remember securing the soft, huggable version of the Blue Chicken from Stardew Valley – it sits proudly on my shelf, serving as a reminder of how I was able to help Shane become the best man he could be.

Their attention to detail, from the quality of materials to the accurate representation of characters, makes each piece feel special.

What sets Sanshee apart is their commitment to authenticity. Each item feels like a tribute to its respective game, rather than just another piece of merchandise. I recall finding a set of enamel pins from “Hollow Knight,” and each pin was a mini work of art, capturing the game’s unique aesthetic perfectly.

In essence, Sanshee is more than a store; it’s a celebration of indie games, a place where each item tells a story, resonating with the heart of a true indie game fan.

Awesome Items to Check out: 

2. FanGamer

If you were a fan of Sanshee, then Fangamer is very much more of the same, only with different products and licenses. Albeit with more of a focus on product variety, offering Vinyl Records, Physical Game Copies, Figurines, and so much more. 

What immediately draws you in where Fangamer is concerned is the ease of access to so many sizable indie collections for top-tier games like Undertale, Outer Wilds, Hades, Tunic, Celeste, and more. Allowing indie fans to immediately find what they are looking for with minimal fuss. 

Then, if you crave a certain layer of authenticity, FanGamer has you covered through their collaboration with indie game developers. This partnership results in merchandise that feels genuinely connected to the games they represent.

Not to mention, some products also have campaigns attached where proceeds will go to suitable charities. For example, the adorable Stray Cat and B12 Plush set sees $9 of all purchases go to Southern Arizona Cat Rescue. 

It’s a store with lots of variety, lots of notable game collections, and a store that is dedicated to offering a space where Indie Fans can shop for merch without feeling like an outcast amongst a sea of AAA merch items. 

Awesome Items to Check out: 

Undertale Mech Collection

Tunic Merch Collection

Stardew Valley Mech Collection

3. Amazon

You may think that Amazon’s offerings are far too broad and unruly to have specific Indie game merch items, but if you are willing to put in the time to search through the mountains of products you’ll likely find a few hidden gems. 

While unearthing these gems takes time and effort, the platform’s strength lies in its convenience and accessibility. You’ll be able to find Indie Game T-Shirts, Figurines, Vinyls, and Plushies. Which, thanks to the global infrastructure of Amazon, could be at your door the following day. 

The only issue is that you cannot always ensure the authenticity of the products. I’ve learned to look for official sellers or direct links from game developers to avoid knock-offs, not to mention making use of Amazon’s user reviews, which offer insights and experiences from fellow gamers. 

Mileage may vary, but for fast shipping, ease of use, and lower prices across the board, Amazon is pretty hard to beat. 

Awesome Items to Check out: 

FNAF Cake Topper Doll 8-Pack

Retro Celeste Mountain T-Shirt

Outer Wilds Solar System Poster

4. PixelCrib

PixelCrib is a paradise for collectors and connoisseurs of indie game merchandise. Offering up a gallery of items that is geared toward those that aren’t against spending a little bit more to get something that is a genuine collector’s item, and tailor-made for fans of each respective game or developer. 

Their focus on quality and exclusivity is what sets them apart. Whether it’s the excitement of acquiring a limited edition art book from “Cuphead,” or the unbridled joy of owning A Complete Undertale Vinyl Collection, you know that when you shop on PixelCrib, you are getting your hands on something special that will probably rise in value the longer you hold onto it. 

They cater to a wide variety of indie game fans, offering limited edition items that will make you the envy of your gaming pals, and if you’re a Vinyl buff who loves collecting gaming soundtracks, this site is hands down the best choice on this list for you. 

For those who appreciate the finer things where Indie Game Merch is concerned, PixelCrib is an invaluable resource. Each visit feels like a new discovery, and a chance to own a piece of the indie games you hold most dear.

Awesome Items to Check out: 

Double Fine Productions 20th Anniversary Legend Book

Stardew Valley Guidebook

Shovel Knight – The Definite Soundtrack Vinyl

5. MakeShip 

MakeShip stands out as a unique platform in the indie merch world through its innovative crowdfunding approach.

It’s a place where fans directly influence what merchandise gets made, a concept I found both empowering and exciting. I just recently participated in the crowdfunding effort for an In Stars and Time Siffrin Plushie, and believe me, it wasn’t the first time I’ve contributed over at MakeShip. 

The site excels in bringing fan ideas to fruition. By supporting a campaign, you’re not just buying a product; you’re helping to create it.

This direct engagement adds a personal touch to every item. Not to mention that each item tends to be of genuine high quality, so you aren’t funding a dud-item; you are getting a genuinely fantastic piece of gaming merch. 

MakeShip is also a great way to support indie developers and artists. Many campaigns are collaborations with creators, ensuring that the merchandise is authentic and true to the spirit of the games. You can’t get more authenticity than a stamp of approval from the creators themselves, now can you?

For those looking to own unique indie game merchandise and enjoy being part of the creative process, MakeShip offers an exciting and rewarding experience.

Awesome Items to Check out: 

Fishbo Moonstone Island Plush

Choo Choo Charles Plush

Bang-On Balls Soviet Ball Plush

6. Yootooz

While Funko is often seen as the Vinyl Figurine manufacturer of choice, YooTooz is definitely the one I would recommend for Indie Game Fans specifically. Yootooz is a delightful destination for those who adore collectible figures that are a little more niche.

Due to Funko tying up so many licenses within major media, YooTooz tends to focus on Content Creators, Pop Culture, and Indie Media, meaning there are plenty of Indie Game options to choose from. 

For example, If you’re a fan of the taboo yet adorable Cult of the Lamb series, then you’ll find a handful of great Vinyl Figures that will look great on your desk, shelf, or anywhere for that matter. Plus, thanks to the size variety, you can find a Figurine that suits your setup nicely. 

The quality of Yootooz figures is exceptional. They strike a perfect balance between playful whimsy and artistic integrity, making them suitable for both display and play.

Plus, Yootooz also stands out for its interactive community engagement. Fans often have a say in what gets produced next, adding a sense of participation and excitement to the collecting experience.

The only downside is that products tend to have a limited run, so you need to constantly be checking the site just in case something you love gets its moment in the spotlight, but even this adds a level of frantic fun and reward to finding the figure of your dreams.

In summary, Yootooz is a haven for fans who want to bring a tangible piece of their indie gaming world into their daily lives.

Discover the Enigmatic World of Hollow Knight | GOG

Immerse yourself in the hauntingly beautiful world of "Hollow Knight," where every step unveils secrets and challenges waiting to be conquered. With its captivating art style and intricate gameplay, embark on an epic journey filled with mystery, danger, and discovery unlike any other.

Check Price
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Awesome Items to Check out: 

Cult of the Lamb Figurine

Maxwell Don’t Starve Figurine

Doki Doki Literature Club Sayori Figurine

Fill Your Shelves! 

So there you have it, six amazing indie merch websites that are sure to have something that you can add to your wishlist in 2024.

Indie games can be hard to acquire bespoke, quality merch worth adding to your collection, but with these websites at hand, it will be easier than ever to make your bedroom or office space an indie game haven.

I hope this helped, and as always, thanks for reading Indie Game Culture. 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top