Best Undertale Toys Guide

Best Undertale Toys Guide

While I undertake this task of revealing our best Undertale Toys article to you, I know it comes down to taste. Don’t fear. There are plenty of options.

As I scour the net, which is my go-to super move for article writing, I see an overwhelming love for Sans the Skeleton. I share the love, but I wanted more than just a list of Sans toys. Thus, I searched further until I found things I would and will one day display in my room.

From plushes to puzzles and figurines to creepy flowers, this best Undertale Toys article will give you plenty to sink your wallet into. If you choose to do so, of course.

Without further delay, let’s look these items over.

Bottom Line Up Front: This will be a Best Undertale Toys guide of the most popular and appealing toys on the internet related to Undertale. No untrusted sites will be used for links, and links will be provided should you want to shop for and purchases any items shown.

best undertale toys guide

Before You Shop

A couple of basic warnings for internet shoppers:

  • Check the integrity of the item by reading reviews on the item itself and the website you’re buying from.
  • Never buy something online that has a no-return policy.
  • Compare prices based not just on their cost but on the cost of shipping and handling.
  • For the most part, I did the math for you on the links provided. As you likely live in a different area than I do, I will provide multiple links where available for you to compare.
  • Never give your information out to a site that doesn’t have a good reputation.
  • You can check a site’s reputation here or here.

Ranking System

I use a basic ranking system for the toys. One that compares them on a scale from poor to exceptional. It looks a little something like this.

Poor-> Okay-> Average-> Medium-> Good-> Great-> High -> The Best 

Criteria

The following are the criteria used to rank each one on the list. The highest averages will go toward the top.

  • Quality: How well the product is made and will hold up over time.
  • Price: How much it costs compared to what you are getting for the money. Not compared to the price of other items.
  • Game Relevance: How relevant is it to a fan of the game.
  • Uniqueness: How does it stand apart from basic toys of the game.
  • Collectible: Does it add much to someone collecting Undertale merchandise.
  • Personal Liking: How much I personally desire the item.

The Toys

#10. The Human

best undertale toys chara and frisk

In one of the most rare game occurrences, the character you play as the player is lower on the love scale than the ones you meet. I think that’s actually incredibly clever myself. In fact, it’s one thing that significantly increases my love for Undertale. Like the human you play, you are interacting with a fantastical world of incredibly unique individuals. Nonetheless, the main character holds a place in your heart if you’ve beaten the game. I found this great deal on a nice plush of the human.

Two different sides of a coin in one package. This is a two-for-one.

  • Quality: Good
  • Price: Good(Great during sales)
  • Game Relevance: High
  • Uniqueness: Average
  • Collectible: Average
  • Personal Liking: Average

Found at the link here: Chara/Human/Frisk

#9 Muddy Tiger Puzzle

best undertale toys muddy tiger puzzle

I take some personal bias here, adding puzzles to a toy article. At the end of the day, a puzzle is also a toy, and some absolutely amazing ones are out there. While browsing Undertale puzzles, there were several Sans and other characters from the Underground-inspired pieces. It was tough to narrow down which one might make this list, but Sans is a fan favorite, and he looks absolutely baller in this Muddy Tiger piece.

Put it together with friends, a loved one, or a life partner. Then you even got some wall art if you like.

  • Quality: Average (some complaints about thin puzzle pieces)
  • Price: Medium
  • Game Relevance: Okay
  • Uniqueness: High
  • Collectible: Average
  • Personal Liking: High

Found at the link here: Sans Puzzle

(Browse the site for more amazing Undertale Puzzles!)

#8 Flowey

best undertale toys flowey

First off, this is not for children. This evil, creepy psychopath of a flower is indeed one of the most brilliant video game villains of all time. It is also far too scary a gift for a child. I couldn’t leave it out. It’s an iconic flower in my mind, right up there with the Piranha Plant from Mario and the rose from Beauty and the Beast. Flowey is a living deity of vileness, and this soft, plushy cute thing somehow encapsulates that entire mood.

Give it to anyone who loves villains, or put it on a shelf with other Undertale merch.

  • Quality: Good
  • Price: Great
  • Game Relevance: High
  • Uniqueness: Medium
  • Collectible: Average
  • Personal Liking: Good

Found at the link here: Flowey Plush

#7 Temmie Plush

best undertale toys temmie plush

This ridiculous adorable character from the game has struck a chord with anyone who has played it. Either as annoying yet still delightful or a mood we wish we could embody. Temmie is a unique and fun addition to Undertale, and their plush is a feel-good item I highly suggest picking up for yourself, a loved one, or a child.

It’s a wonderfully charming addition to a room.

  • Quality: Good
  • Price: Great
  • Game Relevance: High
  • Uniqueness: Medium
  • Collectible: Average
  • Personal Liking: High

Found at the link here: Temmie Dog or on Amazon.

#6 Little Buddies Series 2 Set!

best undertale toys little buddies series 2 set!

This set and the next set are arguably interchangeable with one another on their place in this list. However, if you are going for full collectible standards, you should grab both. These little figurines are nicely designed and can be easily placed anywhere around the house. This first set includes my favorite, Undyne, and Temmie.

It also holds the interesting, as always, Mettaton and Flowey. Its final piece is a rare Alphys, a very important part of the game. Though their design doesn’t lend too well to toys, a good collector would be remiss not to grab one up.

You save a good amount picking up the set, but individual purchases are available on the site.

  • Quality: High
  • Price: Great
  • Game Relevance: High
  • Uniqueness: Medium
  • Collectible: Great
  • Personal Liking: Good

Found at the link here: Little Buddies 2

#5 Little Buddies Series 1 Set!

best undertale toys little buddies series 1 set!

The edge here goes probably to the excellent Papyrus design. He is a very likable figurine. His happiness just beams through here. Not to mention the fan-favorite Sans or how charming Toriel came out. Otherwise, these are the same quality and most other things as the previous set. You get a rare Lesser Dog grab here, though, which is an unexpected pick-up and probably the only place you’ll find one. Another nice “The Human” grab makes an appearance as well.

Deck a shelf/shelves with both sets for the best Undertale game room decor.

  • Quality: High
  • Price: Great
  • Game Relevance: High
  • Uniqueness: Medium
  • Collectible: Great
  • Personal Liking: High (I really like the Papyrus and Toriel figurines)

Found at the link here: Little Buddies 1

#4 Undertale Complete Cast Puzzle

best undertale toys undertale complete cast puzzle

This is my favorite of the puzzles I found online. You get it at society6, and it’s of higher quality than most puzzles sold over the net. It isn’t the quality that makes it so high on the list. It’s that it gorgeously captures the whole cast of Undertale. It can also be picked up as a 1000-piece puzzle for many hours of enjoyment. If you have never put a puzzle together with someone, I suggest giving it a try. It’s a fulfilling experience.

When you finish, this makes a great piece of wall art.

  • Quality: Good
  • Price: Medium
  • Game Relevance: The Best
  • Uniqueness: The Best
  • Collectible: Medium
  • Personal Liking: The Best

Found at the link here: Undertale Puzzle

#3 Papyrus

best undertale toys papyrus

Now we get into the more popular character items. Papyrus is, arguably(unless you killed him), one of the most present NPCs in the Undertale game. We have a great guide on him here on the site, and personally, I found him a delight during my main playthrough.

A big fan of a good plush, I went and hunted through a few options, and believe it or not, I found the version on Wal-Mart to be the best of the bunch. While the score doesn’t add up to some of those I’ve ranked above, it gets boosted due to it being in higher demand than others. Two of these top three can be considered “voted in” by the fans. This is one of them.

He’s a great addition to a room to keep you from feeling down.

  • Quality: Good
  • Price: The Best
  • Game Relevance: High
  • Uniqueness: Average
  • Collectible: Medium
  • Personal Liking: The Best

Found at the link here: Papyrus Plush

#2 The Nendoroid Figurines

best undertale toys the nendoroid figurines

These three figurines are my number one for overall stats, with the Undyne being my favorite. This is also one of the products where you want to check the shipping price to your location before purchasing. The main link I’ll give is for big bad to store, which has a usual flat rate of 4 dollars. But why are these so high up?

They are decent-sized, well-detailed, and fun. You can even change how they look! They come with multiple faces, standing positions, and a few extra bits for customization. Not to mention, outstanding quality.

These are the current top tier in Undertale figurines as of this writing.

  • Quality: The Best
  • Price: Good
  • Game Relevance: High
  • Uniqueness: The Best
  • Collectible: The Best
  • Personal Liking: The Best

Found at the link here: Big Bad Toy Store, or search individually at Nendoroid or Fan Gamer.

#1 Sans

best undertale toys sans

He was always going to be number one. The world at large demanded it, so as someone who even wrote an entire article about him on the site, I would be remiss to argue. Sans is the cool brother we all wish we had. The friend that is always there even if they are a bit lazy.

He does his best in the game to embody a pal, but when push comes to shove, he is the toughest guy in the room. There are a lot of options out there. A good cheap version of his plush can be found at Walmart with the Papyrus earlier. An Amazon search also brings up one, but I chose neither for rank one.

This is Sans with extra eyes and higher quality material compared to those around the net. This is the top Undertale Toy.

  • Quality: The Best(The site is amazing at helping with shipping errors!)
  • Price: Good
  • Game Relevance: The Best(The eyes and the hot dog addition put it above High)
  • Uniqueness: High
  • Collectible: Good
  • Personal Liking: The Best (I do want one)

Found at the link here: Sans Ultimate Plush

FAQs

Question: Where can I buy Undertale Merch?

Answer: Many places online, such as Amazon or Fangamer, sell Undertale Merchandise. You can check your local Walmart as well. They seem to keep the more popular characters in stock. Several other sites are linked throughout this article.

Question: Are there any Undertale Action Figures?

Answer: Currently, no. As of January 2023, that is. Some action figurines could be used as such, but a small child playing with them may break them or lose them easily.

Question: What is Undertale?

Answer: A game where the player is challenged by their usual choices. Unlike most games, where killing is the norm, each monster you slay you come to learn has a significant impact on the world. They were living things, and you didn’t have to kill them. It may be a truly once-in-a-lifetime title, and we encourage you to check it out.

Final Words

You can browse for your personal favorite plush on any of the links listed where a plush is available. You can do what I did if you are strapped for money but want some Undertale love around your desk and pick up one of the figurines instead of a whole set. I got a little Temmie on the way, and I’m excited.

There is no best for everyone, and while this list may give you ideas, I hope it ultimately helps you find the best for you. Like the wonderful game that Undertale is, I endeavor with these articles not to tell you anything. Only to give you more knowledge so as to help you make your own decisions.

Take care and happy shopping.

Latest posts by Bryan Hughes (see all)
Scroll to Top